Ethical Eating Is Easy in New Paltz

New Paltz, New York is home to scenic mountain views, a giant orange and blue painted peace sign, art galleries and tons of local eateries committed to ethical eating.

Various restaurants in New Paltz are dedicated to utilizing the farmlands surrounding the area to feed their costumers. With an ever-growing desire for people to eat and shop local, this Ulster County town and three restaurateurs in particular are answering this international call.

Lagusta’s Luscious Commissary!

Lagusta Yearwoord owns three vegan shops: two in New Paltz, New York (Lagusta’s Luscious Commissary! and Lagusta’s Luscious) and one in Manhattan (Confectionery!).

Lagusta Yearwood sorting fresh produce. Photo by Jess Napp

Lagusta Yearwood became a vegetarian at age 12 when she began to think deeply about meat. According to the entrepreneur, growing up in Phoenix, Arizona sheltered her from alternative plant-based diets. Everything changed for the now local business owner when she began attending meetings for an animal rights group with her mom.

“Everyone there was vegan,” Yearwood said. “We started eating more and more vegan products. It’s so natural to be vegan now.”

Yearwood’s commitment to veganism has spread beyond her personal life and into her businesses—all of which use organic and fair-trade ingredients whenever possible.

  • Sam Manzella is a regular at Commissary! She enjoys their various drinks and sweets such as the lavender lemonade and macarons pictured above.
  • (Sourdough bialy with cashew cream cheese and pumpkin soup) "At Commissary!, the team sources all of their ingredients ethically, and of course, the food and drinks are all vegan," Manzella said.
  • (Matcha latte) "I love Commissary! because it's a place I feel good supporting," Manzella said.
Photos by Sam Manzella

“When I train a new person, I always say, ‘A business makes money because they save on labor, overhead, or inventory, but we don’t save money on any of those things,’” Yearwood said.

Commissary’s! recipes for food are completely determined by their partnership with Long Season Farm, a small farm located in Aquebogue, New York, focused on providing seasonal vegetables. The farmers, Erin and Sam send Yearwood a list of their available produce weekly. Then Yearwood plans menu items around the ingredients.

“I feel like it’s the chef ideal to have a farmer that’s growing stuff just for you,” Yearwood said.

Commissary! has their main food: breakfast soup, cheese plates, beans and greens, (which Yearwood’s staff makes), and then all the specialties that Yearwood concocts. However, among their hearty food exists a plethora of drinks, ranging from every kind of coffee to exotic teas and slushies.

Karma Road

Video by Jess Napp

College student Casey Beyer is one of the many ethically treated employees at Karma Road. She started working there around eleven months ago and has loved it ever since.

“I actually enjoy coming in to work in the morning because everyone who works there is so amazing and my bosses, Seth and Jenn, are incredible,” Beyer said. “It’s a really great environment all around.”

According to Beyer the best part about work is the food. As a vegan, she enjoys being surrounded by delicious vegan food. Beyer mostly does produce shifts, which involve cleaning and prepping veggies for the shop. She said that  one of her favorite things to work with is the fresh produce the eatery provides.

  • An inside look at the deli case where at $6.99 you can get "The AffordaBowl" — a portion of the bean & grain of the day along with a smaller size of any other weighed item in the case.
  • The outside of KR.
  • Table for two?
  • The vegan eateries famous pizza that Seth mentioned.
  • Karma Road's hours of operation.
Photos by Jess Napp

Beyer’s list of favorite dishes at Karma Road is endless, however, she always recommends the baked tofu. It’s a marinated baked tofu patty with their house made walnut pesto, roasted red peppers, lettuce and “Vegenaise” on Bread Alone bread. She admits that if she’s in a decadent mood she’ll add some local sprouts and tempeh bacon.

“I love this dish because the pesto is one of my favorite extras on the menu,” Beyer said. “I usually add it to everything I get there, salads, breakfast, deli items. I eat there every shift because the food is so tasty.”

Beyer has worked in restaurants that are not vegan. She feels better at Karma Road knowing that she is contributing to a business that is not doing any harm to the planet and the creatures that inhabit it. She noticed that this vegan store makes a lot less waste compared to the other places she has worked.

“When I do produce, I prep so many vegetables each day, it’s wild, but it’s amazing because we use all of it,” Beyer said. “Every dish is plant-based, nutritious, ethical and free of harm, which I appreciate so much, as do our customers.”


On-campus nutritionist for the State University of New York at New Paltz Emily Ferencik, believes that what is good for the planet is good for our bodies as well. She said healthy soil produces healthy plants and the same goes for meat and dairy products.

“When we treat our plants and animals with chemicals, pesticides, antibiotics, hormones etc. — it not only pollutes the environment and interrupts the ecosystem, but it decreases the nutritional quality of our food,” Frenecik said.

She said conscious eating is necessary for health on every level. Ferencik defines mindful eating as honoring what your body needs most on a moment-to-moment basis, while being mindful of the environment. She supports veganism and understands that it can meet nutritional needs.

However, Frenecik does not think that everyone’s constitution is suited for it. Yet, with that said, there are certainly ethical ways to operate as an omnivore like: choosing animal products from local farms, keeping animal proteins to a minimum and focusing on plant-based foods to comprise the majority of a diet.

The Village TeaRoom Restaurant & Bake Shop

Co-owner and executive chef Agnes Devereux. Photo by Jess Napp

Co-owner and executive chef of The Village TeaRoom Agnes Devereux is an ethical omnivore and she operates her business that way. It’s been 12 years since the restaurant that was once a two-family home opened its doors.

According to Devereux, when her and her family first moved here from Brooklyn, New York, 16 years ago, she was excited to live near farmlands. However, when they came to New Paltz there wasn’t any local food in the restaurants. She said you could not even buy a local apple at a store in 2004.

“I wanted to open a restaurant that used local ingredients and celebrated the seasons and cooked seasonally,” Devereux said. “It’s a big trend now, but people didn’t know what I was talking about 12 years ago.”

  • One of the most popular desserts on the menu is the Honey Bee Cake.
  • Here is their baker Lindsey in the kitchen making one of these delicious sweet treats.
  • It's a vanilla cake with apricot preserves and honey butter cream.
  • The little bees that adorn the cake are chocolate truffles with delicate almond wings.
  • Bon Appétit!
Photos by Jess Napp

Devereux and her husband started off with a more casual atmosphere during the day with a counter service at lunchtime. In the evening, there remained a single prefixed menu with a vegetarian option, which soon ended and was replaced by a regular menu.

“We wanted to have a restaurant that’s run ethically,” Devereux said. “We run what’s called a triple bottom line business, which focuses on people, planet and profit.”

Devereux recycled an old building and transformed it into a restaurant. She took a lot of the original pieces from the first foundation and reused them. The shelves in the main dining area that house different alcohol are the wooden floor from the initial second story. Various doors were all salvaged from different places and the dining room floor consists of the green product, linoleum.

  • According to Devereux the most popular lunch item on the menu is their "Turkey Pot Pie." It consists of freshly roasted turkey and vegetables in a creamy sauce and an herb biscuit.
  • A pot of tea and a slice of "Shaker Lemon Pie."
  • The shelves made out of the floor boards from the second floor of the original building.
  • "Afternoon Tea" which you can get for one or two with your choice of almond oatmeal scone or lemon scented golden raisins scone with clotted cream, raspberry jam, an assortment of finger sandwiches, a plate of cookies and a pot of tea!
  • One of the reused old doors.
Photos by Jess Napp

The restaurant sources their meat and vegetables from local farmers. Their dairy is local year round and most of their alcohol (beer, cider, vodka, bourbon, wine, etc.) is local, too. A chalkboard sandwiched in between the shelves lists their used farms and it can be found on the cover of the menu as well.

“I love food so I’m an omnivore and I embrace foods of all kinds that are real,” Devereux said. “The Hudson Valley is famous for dairy and its what this area produces. It’s the best in the country, so I embrace those ingredients.”

Jess Napp

My name is Jess Napp and I’m from Mount Kisco, New York. I’m a fourth-year journalism major with a minor in creative writing. My passion is arts writing and I’m on a mission to find the perfect sandwich.

Next Post

The New Paltz Oracle Holds Free Speech Rally

Sun May 7 , 2017
By Thomas Giery Pudney To read the full story, click onto our Atavist page.

You May Like


Twitter feed is not available at the moment.